Does Eating Animal Protein Shorten Your Life? New Research Says No

For years, headlines have painted animal protein as a health villain, linking it to heart disease, cancer, and even early death. Many people have felt pressure to cut meat entirely, often without clear guidance on what to replace it with.

But new research tells a different story. A 2025 study of nearly 16,000 adults found no link between higher animal protein intake and increased risk of death. In fact, participants who ate more animal protein had a slightly lower risk of cancer-related mortality.

So, what does this mean for your diet? Let’s break it down.

The Study at a Glance

Researchers analyzed data from the U.S. NHANES III study, which followed nearly 16,000 adults for health outcomes related to diet.

Key findings:

• Eating more animal protein was not associated with a higher risk of death from any cause.

• People who consumed more animal protein actually had a slightly lower risk of dying from cancer.

• The overall risk was shaped more by diet quality and balance than by the inclusion of animal protein alone.

• 
  

It’s important to note: this was an observational study. That means it can show associations but cannot prove cause and effect. Still, the results challenge the fear-driven message that animal protein shortens lifespan.

Why the Quality of Protein Matters

Not all protein is created equal. The study emphasized that quality and source play a bigger role than whether protein comes from animals or plants.

Best choices for animal protein include:

• Grass-fed beef – Higher in omega-3s and antioxidants compared to conventional beef.

• Pasture-raised poultry – Better fatty acid profile and fewer contaminants.

• Wild-caught fish – Excellent source of omega-3 fatty acids, which support heart and brain health.

• Eggs from pasture-raised hens – Packed with nutrients like choline, vitamin D, and lutein.

  
  

Why the Fear Around Animal Protein?

For decades, nutrition guidelines have warned against saturated fat and red meat, citing links to cardiovascular disease and cancer. However, much of that research was:

• Outdated – Conducted before modern farming and nutrition science advanced.

• Confounded – People eating more red meat often had other lifestyle risk factors (like smoking, low produce intake, or sedentary behavior).

• Overgeneralized – Grouping all meat together (processed hot dogs and grass-fed steak in the same category).

This latest research adds nuance: the story isn’t about eliminating an entire food group, but about choosing quality sources and maintaining overall balance.

The Role of Protein in Longevity

Protein plays essential roles in the body that directly support healthy aging:

• Muscle maintenance – Prevents sarcopenia (age-related muscle loss) and supports mobility.

• Metabolic health – Helps stabilize blood sugar and maintain energy.

• Immune function – Provides amino acids needed for antibodies and healing.

• Hormone balance – Supports healthy production of neurotransmitters and hormones.

Cutting protein too low in the name of “health” can backfire, especially for older adults who need more to maintain strength and resilience.

Practical Tips for Including Animal Protein Wisely

If you choose to include animal protein in your diet, here’s how to do it in a health-supportive way:

1. Focus on quality – Choose grass-fed, pasture-raised, and wild-caught whenever possible.

2. Balance your plate – Pair protein with fiber-rich vegetables, fruits, and whole grains to reduce inflammation and support gut health.

3. Don’t forget variety – Mix animal proteins with plant proteins like beans, lentils, and nuts for a broad nutrient spectrum.

4. Limit processed meats – Deli meats, hot dogs, and heavily processed sausages are still linked with negative health outcomes.

Functional Medicine Perspective

In functional medicine, we don’t demonize whole food groups, we ask how they fit into the big picture of each individual’s health.

For some patients, higher protein intake supports blood sugar balance, hormone health, and energy. For others, digestive health or autoimmune conditions may guide different recommendations.

The point isn’t “animal protein is good” or “animal protein is bad.” It’s: What does your unique body need, and how do we optimize food quality and balance?

The Bottom Line

The latest evidence shows that eating animal protein, when chosen wisely and paired with a nutrient-dense diet, does not increase risk of death and may even provide protective benefits.

Instead of stressing about whether to eat meat at all, focus on:

• Quality sources (grass-fed, pasture-raised, wild-caught)

• Balance with plants, fiber, and healthy fats

• Personalization based on your health history and goals

Food is information for your body. With the right approach, protein whether plant or animal can be part of a longevity-supporting diet.

👉 Curious how functional medicine creates personalized nutrition strategies that take the guesswork out of eating? Schedule a consultation to explore how we can support your health goals.